Back to Advice Goddess

ASK AMY: Baby makes flee

Nobody's Dad and Chosen have issues

Amy Alkon

Email Article Print Article Share on Facebook Share on Reddit Share on StumbleUpon

QUESTION: When I married five years ago, I was on the fence about having kids. I thought some parental gene might kick in, but it never did. Now, at 40, I've accepted that a childless marriage is best for us, given my wife's fertility issues and my ambivalence about parenthood. My wife, however, sees no purpose to life without children. It upsets her to see me happy without kids while she pines for them. She is also upset that I won't try all possible alternatives, such as adoption and fertility treatments, and is generally angry and outright hostile toward me. - Nobody's Dad

ANSWER: There are things it's Ok to procrastinate on, like cleaning behind the toilet. If you're like me, as soon as you look back there and see new plant life cropping up (and, OK, maybe a woodpecker and a couple of deer), you break out the bleach and it's all good. But, procrastinate on figuring out whether to have a family? There you were: "Let's see, should we create another human being, spend 20-plus years and hundreds of thousands of dollars raising it? I dunno ... let's just sign this contract to spend the rest of our lives together and figure it out later."

Chances are, you both had baby-related plots brewing in your heads. You maybe thought you'd ignore the issue and it might go away. Your wife maybe figured she'd get pregnant, you'd just have to go along, and the moment you saw the baby you'd melt into a loving father. But, whoops, fertility issues crept in. You can get accidentally pregnant, but you can't accidentally adopt a child, as in, you're driving along one day, glance into the back seat and notice a 6-year-old Romanian orphan coloring on the headrest.

Although you can't offer any solutions that work for your wife, you do see a number of alternatives that work for you: not having kids, having no kids, remaining childless. There is one other alternative: getting divorced so your wife can try to find a man who's interested in being a dad ... as dim a prospect as that may be for a fertility-challenged 40-year-old woman competing with pert-breasted, fertility-iconish 20-somethings. Obviously, this option is not exactly the fast track to happily ever after. Then again, that's probably not in the cards here unless you two can somehow find some wiggle room in how she "sees no purpose to life without children" and how you aren't up for adopting anything you can't pat on the head and leave tied to a chain-link fence.


QUESTION: I recently married and should be bathed in newlywed bliss, but a rock star in a famous alternative band wants me to have an affair with him. I'm shocked and thrilled, to say the least. My conscience says, "Are you insane? You love your husband and chose him for a reason. Don't jeopardize that!" But I'm also hearing "You only live once, and thousands of women wish they had this guy's attention." - Chosen

ANSWER: You said "I do," not "I'd do a rock star first chance I get." (If only you'd known you'd meet this guy, you could've asked your husband for the indie rock star exception to lifelong fidelity.) Yes, thrillingly, of all the hipster girls in black-rimmed glasses and earnest T-shirts worn ironically, he wants you. This says something about you - probably that you are conveniently located, reasonably attractive, and don't seem the type to poke holes in the condom. Wow. The romance. 

You're buying into groupiethink - the idea that you're somebody if you have sex with somebody famous. But, he's just a guy. He stinks up the bathroom same as any other guy. Okay, the fame fairy touched him with her magic wand. Maybe not because he's so much more talented than the next guy with a guitar but because he was in the right place at the right time with the right chin. If his gig were at the coffee shop instead of Coachella and his panting fans were his two dogs tied up outside, would your panties still be flying off?

Remember that guy you stood next to in the big white dress? Weren't you two eventually supposed to be holding hands in twin rockers on the porch of the old folks home? If you're going to jeopardize everything you have with him, just be clear on what you could end up having and holding instead - a 50-year-old memory of some musician whispering those romantic words every woman longs to hear: "How ‘bout we have sex for a couple hours and then I see if there are any other cute girls outside the tour bus?"

(c)2012, Amy Alkon, all rights reserved. Got a problem? Write Amy Alkon, 171 Pier Ave, #280, Santa Monica, CA  90405, or e-mail. Weekly radio show:

Read Amy Alkon's book: I SEE RUDE PEOPLE: One woman's battle to beat some manners into impolite society (McGraw-Hill, $16.95)

comments powered by Disqus