No argument here

Denzel Washington’s new film about an underdog debate team is one of the year’s best films

By Roger Ebert on December 27, 2007

“The Great Debaters” is about an underdog debate team that wins a national championship, and some critics have complained that it follows the formula of all sports movies by leading up, through great adversity, to a victory at the end.  So it does.  How many sports movies, or movies about underdogs competing in any way, have you seen that end in defeat?  It is human nature to seek inspiration in victory, and this is a film that is affirming and inspiring and re-creates the stories of a remarkable team and their coach. 

The team is from little Wiley College in Marshall, Texas, an African-American institution in the heart of the Jim Crow South of the 1930s.  The school’s English professor, Melvin Tolson (Denzel Washington), is a taskmaster who demands the highest standards from his debate team, and they’re rewarded with a national championship.  That’s what the “sports movie” is about, but the movie is about so much more, and in ways that do not follow formulas. 

There are, for example, Tolson’s secret lives.  Dressed in overalls and work boots, he ventures out incognito as an organizer for a national sharecropper’s union.  He’s a dangerous radical, the local whites believe, probably a communist.  But he’s organizing both poor whites and blacks, whose servitude is equal.  He keeps his politics out of the classroom, however, where he conceals a different kind of secret: He is one of America’s leading poets.  Yes, although the movie barely touches on it, Tolson published long poems in such magazines as The Atlantic Monthly, and in 1947 was actually named poet laureate of Liberia.  Ironic, that his role as a debate coach would win him greater fame today. 

He holds grueling auditions and selects four team members: Henry Lowe (Nate Parker), who drinks and fools around but is formidably intelligent; Hamilton Burgess (Jermaine Williams), a superb debater; James Farmer Jr. (Denzel Whitaker), a precocious 14-year-old who is their researcher; and Samantha Booke (Jurnee Smollett), the substitute and only female debater they’ve heard of.  Tolson drills them, disciplines them, counsels them, and leads them to a string of victories that results in a triumph over Harvard, the national champion. 

We get a good sense of the nurturing black community that has produced these students, in particular James Farmer Sr. (Forest Whitaker), a preacher (young Denzel Whitaker, as his son, is no relation, and not named after Washington, for that matter).  James Jr. would go on to found the Congress of Racial Equality (CORE).  Tolson drives his team on long road trips to out-of-town debates, and one night traveling late, they have the defining emotional experience of the film: They happen upon a scene where a white mob has just lynched a black man and set his body afire.  They barely escape with their own lives.  And daily life for them is fraught with racist peril; especially for Tolson, who has been singled out by the local sheriff as a rabble-rouser.  These experiences inform their debates as much as formal research. 

The movie is not really about how this team defeats the national champions.  It is more about how its members, its coach, its school and community believe that an education is their best way out of the morass of racism and discrimination.  They would find it unthinkable that decades in the future, serious black students would be criticized by jealous contemporaries for “acting white.”  They are black, proud, single-minded, focused, and it all expresses itself most dramatically in their debating. 

The debates themselves have one peculiarity: The Wiley team always somehow draws the “good” side of every question.  Since a debate team is supposed to defend whatever position it draws, it might have been intriguing to see them defend something they disbelieve, even despise.  Still, I suppose I understand why that isn’t done here; it would have interrupted the flow.  And the flow becomes a mighty flood, in a powerful and impassioned story.  This is one of the year’s best films. 

Note: In actual fact, the real Wiley team did beat the national champions, but from USC, not Harvard.  Screenwriter Robert Eisele explains, “In that era, there was much at stake when a black college debated any white school, particularly one with the stature of Harvard.  We used Harvard to demonstrate the heights they achieved.” 


Denzel Washington, Forest Whitaker and Nate Parker

Director: Denzel Washington

Rated: PG-13 for depiction of strong thematic material including violence and disturbing images, and for language and brief sexuality